“We picked each other.”
That’s how chef Theo Adley describes opening Marigold—the little restaurant that has garnered unexpected recognition from titans like the James Beard Foundation and Wine Enthusiast—in Lyons, a town of 2,200 that hadn’t exactly been known as a culinary destination.
In his two decades in Colorado, Adley has cooked all over the state, starting at a “socio-anarchic breakfast joint” in Boulder before moving on to the not-so-anarchic Flagstaff House and Frasca Food and Wine.
He worked in the mountains at Aspen’s Little Nell and Dunton Hot Springs, and he cheffed in Denver at The Squeaky Bean and The Populist. More than a decade ago Adley opened—and then closed—his first restaurant, The Pinyon, in Boulder.
He’s done delicious things at prestigious places. But, with Marigold, it feels like Adley is fully stepping into his culinary identity. Where his only confines are what’s fresh that day and how weird he wants to get. Because that’s the thing with the daily changing menu at Marigold: It’s a little weird.
Take the standard-sounding Caesar salad, for example. Except, at Marigold, it’s anything but standard: It’s now a handheld bite topped with puffed rice for crunch and bonito flakes standing in for the classic anchovies. Or a recent raw scallop dish, paired with foie gras consommé, some mushrooms and pomelo. There’s fried chicken, but—surprise!—it’s guinea fowl, and let’s top it with shaved truffles. There’s pretty much always a fresh pasta option on the dinner menu—some coated in a long-simmered beef ragu, others dotted with prawns and chile crisp, bobbing in lobster stock.
“We want it to be interesting,” says Adley. “Draw that line between having something taste almost familiar, but have a quiet hominess, a comfortable deliciousness. But also just a little weird.”
And Lyons is the perfect place for weird. The little town is known for its arts and music scene, its outdoor opportunities and its many funky local businesses. Lyons residents are quirky and creative, and they most certainly support their own. Adley didn’t plan on opening Marigold there—he got priced out of Boulder and had been browsing the surrounding towns of Lafayette, Longmont and Louisville—but now he can’t imagine his restaurant being anywhere else.
“It’s been such a crazy, long road to get to this place. The ethos of Marigold, my wife and I have talked about this exact restaurant for so long now, well over a decade. We spent a lot of time meditating about the community we wanted to be in and support … Then my wife came across this listing, this cute little space with all the infrastructure we needed, in a town we love. It all gelled and made sense,” he says.
After Marigold opened in the summer of 2022, Lyons locals immediately began supporting it. Then, the Boulderites started making the drive up U.S. 36. Then, people from Estes Park and Longmont came, too. Word spread quickly and, soon, diners were making the hour-long drive up from Denver, just to have dinner in this tiny restaurant in Lyons.
That kind of pressure might be grueling for some. But for Adley and his team, it’s a fun challenge. They know that those Denver diners have high expectations, so they’d better knock it out of the park. “You can get a lot of negative Yelps done in that hour drive home,” Adley jokes.
Really, though, the Marigold team is cooking for themselves and their neighbors. They’re combining flavors that they want to eat, using ingredients they’re proud to source. Adley and his kitchen staff are pushing themselves to master different techniques and think creatively and differently about food. And little Lyons is just the place for it.
“It’s a tiny town, but Lyons has a huge heart to it,” Adley says. “If you wait long enough and are tenacious enough, you’ll find what fits. We love Lyons. It’s super tight-knit.”
With Marigold, Adley has manifested the community restaurant he always wanted. He’s having fun and keeping it weird. Whoever picked who, it’s clear that Marigold and Lyons are a delicious match. “It’s a fun time,” he says. “We just get to do our thing in the woods.”
link